09-12-2025 Mains Question Answer
Examine the role of the Finance Commission in promoting cooperative federalism in India. Provide recent examples to support your argument.
The Finance Commission, established under Article 280, serves as a constitutional bridge between the Centre and states, operationalizing cooperative federalism through equitable resource distribution and collaborative fiscal governance.
Promoting Cooperative Federalism
- Constitutional Mandate: Recommends principles for distributing the divisible pool of taxes between Centre and states, embodying fiscal federalism enshrined in the Constitution.
- Participatory Process: The 16th Finance Commission actively engages with states to gather devolution suggestions, demonstrating inclusive dialogue rather than unilateral Centre decisions.
- Revenue Deficit Management: The 15th FC recommended ₹3 lakh crore revenue deficit grants to 17 states (2021-26), enabling weaker states to maintain essential services.
- Equalization Principle: Uses criteria like income distance, area, and population to ensure horizontal devolution addresses regional disparities while promoting balanced development.
- Institutional Dialogue: Regular consultations with state governments create platforms for federal negotiation rather than Centre-state confrontation on fiscal matters.
Recent Developments in Federal Cooperation
- Goa’s Devolution Proposal (January 2025): Suggested increasing states’ share from 41% to 50% in vertical devolution, showing institutional channels for fair resource negotiation.
- SDG Integration: Goa proposed 12.5% weightage for SDG compliance in horizontal devolution, illustrating multi-dimensional development priorities beyond income measures.
- Tax Effort Recognition: Proposal to increase tax effort weightage from 2.5% to 5% incentivizes fiscal responsibility while maintaining federal equity.
- Cesses Cap Demand: States requesting limits on Centre’s cesses reflects concerns about parallel revenue mobilization affecting state shares.
- Performance-Based Allocation: Recent emphasis on linking devolution to governance indicators promotes healthy competition among states.
The Finance Commission operationalizes Articles 268-293 (taxation powers), converting constitutional federalism into functional fiscal architecture. It ensures resource scarcity doesn’t undermine state governance while maintaining macroeconomic stability through collaborative federal mechanisms.